Academic freedom in national constitutions: an initial comparative study
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7213/rev.dir.econ.soc.v16i2.32372Palavras-chave:
Academic freedom; scientific freedom; autonomy of higher education institutions; constitution; customary international law.Resumo
Constitutions are a particularly significant expression of State practice and of opinio juris, the two constitutive elements of customary international law. The question of whether academic freedom has attained the status of customary international law has not been squarely addressed in international legal scholarship, nor by national or international adjudicative bodies. This article intends to contribute to the debate by mapping “academic freedom” and cognate concepts in national constitutions. The introduction presents the reader first the concept of customary international law and, second, the elusive notion of academic freedom. Then, the article introduces the Academic Freedom in Constitutions (AFC) database and makes a few historical observations regarding the diffusion of academic freedom in world constitutions. However, because the AFC database allows only for quantitative and trend analysis, the article dwells next into the text of relevant “academic freedom” constitutional provisions. In particular, it tracks and analyzes mentions of “academic freedom”, “scientific freedom”, “autonomy of higher education institutions” and equivalent expressions in world constitutions. The article draws also some observations regarding limitations in constitutions to “academic freedom” provisions. Of course, an analysis of academic freedom constitutional provisions cannot per se be dispositive of whether academic freedom has attained customary international law status. It must be complemented by a deeper and more robust research. Yet, it adds a piece to the puzzle.
Downloads
Referências
ALBANIA. Constitution of 1998 (amended 2012).
ALGERIA. Constitution of 1996 (amended 2016).
ANGOLA. Constitution of 2010.
ARGENTINA. Constitution of 1853 (reinst. 1983; rev. 1994).
ARMENIA. Constitution of 1995 (rev. 2015).
AUSTRIA. Constitution of 1920 (reinst. 1945; amended 2013).
AZERBAIJAN. Constitution of 1995 (rev. 2016).
BAHRAIN. Constitution of 2002.
BEITER, Klaus; KARRAN, Terence; APPIAGYEI-ATUA, Kwadwo. Yearning to belong: finding a home for the right to acaemic freedom in the UN Human Rights Covenants. Intercultural Human Rights Law Review, v. 11, p. 107–190, 2016.
BINGHAM, Tom. The rule of law. Penguin, 2010.
BRAZIL. Constitution of 1988 (amended 2004).
BULGARIA. Constitution of 1991 (rev. 2015).
BURKINA FASO. Constitution of 1991 (amended 2015).
CAPE VERDE. Constitution of 1992.
CHILE. Constitution of 1980 (rev. 2021).
CHINA. Constitution of 1982 (amended 2018).
CLASSEN, Peter. On the history of ‘academic freedom’, primarily in the Middle Ages. Historical Journal, v. 232, p. 529 - 553, 1981.
COGHLAN, Niall; STEIERT, Marc (ed.). The Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union: the 'travaux préparatoires' and selected documents. European University Institute, 2020. Available at: https://cadmus.eui.eu/handle/1814/68959.
COLOMBIA. Constitution of 1991 (rev. 2015).
COSTA RICA. Constitution of 1949 (rev. 2020).
CROATIA. Constitution of 1990 (amended 2001).
CUBA. Constitution of 2019.
CZECH REPUBLIC. Constitution of 1993 (rev. 2013).
DEMOCRATIC PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF KOREA. Constitution of 1972 (amended 1998).
DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO. Constitution of 2006 (amended 2011).
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC. Constitution of 2015.
ECO, Umberto. Mouse or rat?: translation as negotiation. Phoenix Literature, 2003.
ECUADOR. Constitution of 2008 (rev. 2021).
EGYPT. Constitution of 2014.
EL SALVADOR. Constitution of 1983 (rev. 2014).
ERITREA. Constitution of 1997.
ESTONIA. Constitution of 1992 (amended 2005).
ESTONIA. Constitution of the Republic of Estonia, 1920. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
EUROPEAN UNION. Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. Official Journal of the Euro-pean Union, C83, v. 53, p. 380, 2010.
FIJI. Constitution of 2013.
FINLAND. Constitution of 1999 (amended 2007).
FINLAND. Constitution of the Republic of Finland, 1919. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
FINNIS, John. Natural law and natural rights. Clarendon Press, 1980.
FULLER, Lon. The morality of law. Yale University Press, 1964.
GAMBIA (THE). Constitution of 1996 (rev. 2018).
GEORGIA. Constitution of 1995 (rev. 2018).
GEORGIA. Constitution of Georgia, 1921. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
GERMANY. Basic Law of 1949 (amended 2012).
GERMANY. Constitution of the German Empire, 1919 (Weimar Constitution). In: German History in Documents and Images, v. 6. Weimar Germany, 1918/19–1933. Available at: https://germanhistorydocs.ghi-dc.org/pdf/eng/ghi_wr_weimarconstitution_Eng.pdf.
GERMANY. Constitution, 1849. German Constituent National Assembly (Frankfurt Constitution / Paulskir-chenverfassung).
GHANA. Constitution of 1992 (rev. 1996).
GODERIS, Benedikt; VERSTEEG, Mila. The diffusion of constitutional rights. International Review of Law and Economics, v. 39, p. 1–19, 2014.
GREECE. Constitution of 1975 (amended 2008).
GROTE, Rainer. Definition of constitutions. In GROTE, Rainer, LACHENMANN, Frauke, WOLFRUM, Rüdiger (ed.). Max Planck Encyclopedia of Comparative Constitutional Law (online ed.). Mar. 2018.
GUATEMALA. Constitution of 1985 (rev. 1993).
GUINEA-BISSAU. Constitution of 1984 (amended 1996).
HAITI. Constitution of 1987 (rev. 2012).
HONDURAS. Constitution of 1982 (rev. 2013).
HUNGARY. Constitution of 1949 (amended 2007).
ICELAND. Constitution of 1944 (amended 1999).
INDONESIA. Constitution of 1945 (reinst. 1959; rev. 2002).
INTER-AMERICAN COMMISSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS. Declaration of Inter-American Principles on Academic Freedom and University Autonomy. Adopted on 9 Dec. 2021. Available at: https://www.oas.org/en/iachr/reports/questionnaires/2021_principiosinteramericanos_libertadacademica_autonomiauniversitaria_eng.pdf.
INTERNATIONAL LAW COMMISSION (ILC). Draft conclusions on identification of customary inter-national law.
A/CN.4/L.892, United Nations, 2018.
ITALY. Constitution of 1947 (amended 2012).
JAPAN. Constitution of 1946.
JORDAN. Constitution of 1952 (amended 2014).
KENYA. Constitution of 2010.
KOREA (REPUBLIC OF). Constitution of 1948 (rev. 1987).
KOSOVO. Constitution of 2008.
KUWAIT. Constitution of 1962 (reinst. 1992).
KYRGYZSTAN. Constitution of 2010.
LAOS. Constitution of 1991 (amended 2003).
LATVIA. Constitution of 1922 (amended 2005).
LIBERIA. Constitution of 1986.
LITHUANIA. Constitution of 1992 (amended 2006).
MADAGASCAR. Constitution of 2010.
MALAWI. Constitution of 1994 (rev. 2017).
MAURITANIA. Constitution of 1991 (amended 2006).
MCBAIN, Howard Lee; ROGERS, Lindsay. New constitutions of europe. Doubleday, Page & Company, p.343-378, 1922.
MEXICO. Constitution of 1917 (rev. 2015).
MOLDOVA. Constitution of 1994 (amended 2003).
MONTENEGRO. Constitution of 2007.
MOROCCO. Constitution of 2011.
MOZAMBIQUE. Constitution of 2004 (rev. 2007).
MYANMAR. Constitution of 2008.
NAMIBIA. Constitution of 1990 (rev. 2014).
NICARAGUA. Constitution of 1986 (amended 2005).
NORTH MACEDONIA. Constitution of 1991 (rev. 2011).
PALESTINE. Constitution of 2003.
PANAMA. Constitution of 1972 (rev. 2004).
PARAGUAY. Constitution of 1992 (rev. 2011).
PERU. Constitution of 1993 (amended 2005).
PHILIPPINES. Constitution of 1987.
POLAND. Constitution of 1997 (rev. 2009).
PORTUGAL. Constitution of 1976 (amended 2004).
QATAR. Constitution of 2003.
RAWLS, John. A theory of justice. Harvard University Press, 1999.
RAZ, Joseph. The rule of law and its virtue. In RAZ, Joseph. The Authority of Law. Oxford University Press, 1979.
ROBERTS LYER, Kirsten; SALIBA, Ilyas; SPANNAGEL, Janika. University autonomy decline: causes, res-ponses, and implications for academic freedom. Routledge, 2022.
ROMANIA. Constitution of 1991 (rev. 2003).
ROMANO, Cesare; BOGGIO, Andrea. The human right to science: history, development and nor-mative content. Oxford University Press, 2024.
ROMANO, Cesare; BOGGIO, Andrea. The right to benefit from progress in science and technology. Max Planck Encyclopedia of Comparative Constitutional Law. Oct. 2020.
RUSSIA. Constitution of 1993 (amended 2014).
SÃO TOMÉ AND PRÍNCIPE. Constitution of 1975 (amended 2003).
SERBIA. Constitution of 2006.
SIERRA LEONE. Constitution of 1991 (reinst. 1996; rev. 2013).
SLOVAKIA. Constitution of 1992 (amended 2006).
SLOVENIA. Constitution of 1991 (amended 2003).
SOMALIA. Constitution of 2012.
SOUTH AFRICA. Constitution of 1996 (amended 2013).
SOUTH SUDAN. Constitution of 2011 (amended 2015).
SPAIN. Constitution of 1978 (rev. 2011).
SPAIN. Constitution of the Spanish Republic, 1931. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
SPANNAGEL, Janika. Academic Freedom in Constitutions (AFC) Dataset (1789–2022). Harvard Dataverse, v. 2, 2023.
Available at: https://dataverse.harvard.edu/file.xhtml?fileId=6988679&version=2.0. Acess in: 14 mar. 2024.
SPANNAGEL, Janika. Introducing academic freedom in constitutions: A New Global Dataset: 1789–2022. Euro-pean Political Science, v. 23, p. 421-432, 2024. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41304-023-00446-5. Acess in: 14 mar. 2024.
STARCK, Christian. Freedom of scientific research and its restrictions in german constitutional law. Israel Law Review, v. 39, p. 110-126, 2006.
STATUTE OF THE INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE. 33 UNTS 993, 26 June 1945.
SUDAN. Constitution of 2019.
SURINAME. Constitution of 1987.
SWITZERLAND. Constitution of 1999 (rev. 2014).
SYRIAN ARAB REPUBLIC. Constitution of 2012.
THAILAND. Constitution of 2017.
THORENS, Justin. Liberties, freedom and autonomy: a few reflections on academia’s estate. Higher Educa-tion Policy, v. 19, p. 87–110, 2006.
TREVES, Tullio. Customary international law. In WOLFRUM, Rüdiger (ed.), Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law (online edn.). Nov. 2006.
TUNISIA. Constitution of 2014.
TURKEY. Constitution of 1982 (amended 2010).
TURKMENISTAN. Constitution of 2008 (rev. 2016).
UGANDA. Constitution of 1995 (rev. 2017).
UKRAINE. Constitution of 1996 (amended 2014).
UNITED NATIONS COMMITTEE ON ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND CULTURAL RIGHTS. General Comment No. 13: the right to education (Art. 13 of the Covenant). E/C.12/1999/10, 8 Dec. 1999.
UNITED NATIONS EDUCATIONAL, SCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL ORGANIZATION (UNESCO). Recommendation concerning the status of higher-education teaching personnel. Adopted by the General Confe-rence on 11 Nov. 1997. Available at: https://en.unesco.org/about-us/legal-affairs/recommendation-concerning-status-higher-education-teaching-personnel.
UNITED NATIONS. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Treaty Series, v. 999, p. 171, 1966.
UNITED NATIONS. International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights. Treaty Se-ries, v. 999, p. 171, 1966.
UNITED NATIONS. Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 217 A (III), 10 Dec. 1948.
UNITED NATIONS. Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT). Adopted on 23 May 1969. Uni-ted Nations Treaty Series, v. 1155.
URUGUAY. Constitution of 1966 (reinst. 1985; rev. 2004).
URUGUAY. Constitution of the Oriental Republic of Uruguay, 1917. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
UZBEKISTAN. Constitution of 1992 (rev. 2011).
VENEZUELA (BOLIVARIAN REPUBLIC OF). Constitution of 1999 (rev. 2009).
VIET NAM. Constitution of 1992 (rev. 2013).
YEMEN. Constitution of 1991 (rev. 2015).
YUGOSLAVIA. Constitution of the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes ("Vidovdan Consti-tution"), 1921. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
YUGOSLAVIA. Constitution of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, 1963. Available at: https://home.heinonline.org/content/world-constitutions-illustrated/.
ZIMBABWE. Constitution of 2013 (rev. 2017).
ZWIRNER, Henning. Zum Grundrecht der Wissenschaftsfreiheit. Archiv des öffentlichen Rechts, v. 98, p. 313-339, 1973.
Downloads
Publicado
Como Citar
Edição
Seção
Licença
Copyright (c) 2025 Cesare Romano
Este trabalho está licenciado sob uma licença Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Autores que publicam nesta revista concordam com os seguintes termos:
- Autores mantém os direitos autorais e concedem à revista o direito de primeira publicação, com o trabalho simultaneamente licenciado sob a Creative Commons - Atribuição 4.0 Internacional que permite o compartilhamento do trabalho com reconhecimento da autoria e publicação inicial nesta revista.
- Autores têm autorização para assumir contratos adicionais separadamente, para distribuição não-exclusiva da versão do trabalho publicada nesta revista (ex.: publicar em repositório institucional ou como capítulo de livro), com reconhecimento de autoria e publicação inicial nesta revista.
- Autores têm permissão e são estimulados a publicar e distribuir seu trabalho online (ex.: em repositórios institucionais ou na sua página pessoal) a qualquer ponto antes ou durante o processo editorial, já que isso pode gerar alterações produtivas, bem como aumentar o impacto e a citação do trabalho publicado (Veja O Efeito do Acesso Livre).
